Terminology
/General
Mechanical vs. Electrical Tachometers: A Comparison
This article compares mechanical and electrical tachometers, focusing on their operating principles, components, and differences in accuracy and maintenance.
2 min read
Advertisement
Table of Contents
This article explores the differences between DC and AC tachometer generators, both of which are used to measure the angular velocity of a rotating shaft.
A tachometer is an instrument that measures the rotational speed of a shaft. It can do this by either counting the total revolutions during a specific period or by directly displaying the revolutions per minute (RPM).
The DC tachometer generator (as shown in Fig. 1) uses a small armature connected to the machine whose speed is being measured. This armature spins within a magnetic field created by a permanent magnet. The voltage (electromotive force or EMF) generated is directly proportional to the product of the magnetic flux and the speed of rotation. Since the flux of the permanent magnet is constant, the generated voltage is directly proportional to the speed of the shaft.
Fig 1: DC tachometer generator
The polarity of the output voltage from a DC tachometer indicates the direction of rotation, making it suitable for applications where this information is important.
The AC tachometer generator (as depicted in Fig. 2) utilizes a rotating magnet, which can be either a permanent magnet or an electromagnet. The coil is wound around the stator. As the magnet rotates, it induces an EMF in the coil of the stator. The amplitude and frequency of this induced EMF are proportional to the speed of rotation.
Fig 2: AC tachometer generator
Unlike the DC tachometer, the AC tachometer is primarily used for measuring speed in one direction.
The following table summarizes the key differences between DC and AC tachometer generators:
| Feature | DC Tachometer Generator | AC Tachometer Generator |
|---|---|---|
| Direction Measurement | Measures speed in both directions. | Measures speed in one direction only. |
| Construction | Uses a horseshoe-type permanent magnet. | Typically uses a single stator and rotor arrangement or a squirrel cage setup. |
| Speed Measurement | Uses a moving coil voltmeter to measure speed. | Uses a moving coil instrument with either a permanent magnet or an electromagnet. |
Advertisement
Terminology
/General
This article compares mechanical and electrical tachometers, focusing on their operating principles, components, and differences in accuracy and maintenance.
Equipments
/Electronics
Learn about tachometers, devices used to measure the angular velocity (RPM) of rotating objects like motor shafts. Discover common types and manufacturers.
Articles
/Measurements
A detailed comparison of moving coil (MC) and moving iron (MI) instruments, including their operating principles, types, and key differences.